Selected menu has been deleted. Please select the another existing nav menu.

Is Using AI to Grade Leaving Cert Work Ethical?

Revolutionizing Education: Cillian Ó Fathaigh’s Journey with Pulc.AI

From Humble Beginnings to Innovative Solutions

Cillian Ó Fathaigh’s unexpected rise to fame began in 2010 when he made headlines for selling his Leaving Cert notes on eBay for an astonishing €3,000. While his friends still tease him about this unique claim to fame, it set the stage for a remarkable journey into the world of education technology.

The Spark of Inspiration: A Year of Advice

Following his eBay success, Ó Fathaigh penned a year-long series of articles titled “Secrets of My Success” for The Irish Times. This venture aimed to guide students through the maze of study techniques for various subjects, offering insights that would later influence his innovative project, Pulc.AI.

A Mission Rooted in Education

Now serving as an assistant professor in philosophy, Ó Fathaigh reflects on his ongoing commitment to education, which has been a constant in his life for over 15 years. "The Irish second-level education system is something I’ve been passionate about for a long time, especially as inequalities have become more pronounced," he states.

Introducing Pulc: The Future of Assessment

At the heart of Ó Fathaigh’s latest endeavor is Pulc, an AI tool designed to transform how students and teachers interact with educational content. With a simple upload from either students or teachers, Pulc analyzes the work and provides feedback akin to that of a Leaving Cert marker. This innovation aims to significantly ease the burden of grading for teachers.

Empowering Teachers with AI

“What this tool does is generate feedback,” Ó Fathaigh explains. He emphasizes that while Pulc produces assessments, it maintains teacher control. Educators can edit, approve, or delete comments, ensuring that the personal touch remains intact. This not only saves time but also enhances the quality of feedback students receive.

Not a Replacement, But a Support System

Ó Fathaigh is clear about Pulc’s intentions: “It’s not trying to replace teachers.” He acknowledges the mastery and creativity that educators bring to their roles, emphasizing that Pulc is designed to support teachers, allowing them to focus more on direct teaching rather than spending countless hours on corrections.

A Growing Community of Users

Since its inception, approximately 500 teachers have started integrating Pulc into their classrooms. Ó Fathaigh and his co-founder, Charles Dillon, a mathematician and quantitative trader, began developing the platform full-time in January. They aim for a broader rollout by September, with plans for the tool to operate in Irish across all subjects, addressing concerns about accessibility in Gaelscoileanna.

An Academic with a Vision

Ó Fathaigh is not just a tech innovator but also a scholar. With a master’s and PhD from Cambridge, he has worked as a Marie Curie fellow in Poland. His recent experiences at King’s College London exposed him to the challenges of unauthorized AI usage among students, fueling his interest in ethical AI applications in education.

Ethical Dilemmas in AI Assessment

As Pulc gains traction, it also raises ethical questions around AI in education. Concerns about potential cheating among Leaving Cert candidates have emerged, particularly regarding the fairness of using AI for grading when students are restricted from using it in their submissions. This dilemma places teachers in a challenging position as they navigate the evolving landscape of educational technology.

The Complexity of Irish Education

In his development of Pulc, Ó Fathaigh scrutinized the Irish syllabus, comparing it to his own educational experiences. He identifies areas vulnerable to AI’s influence, similar to how grind schools have impacted traditional learning. Adapting to these changes is complex, but essential.

A Slow but Steady Evolution

“Education must evolve cautiously,” Ó Fathaigh remarks. He notes that the elements of traditional rote learning still prevail in many educational practices, highlighting the need for thoughtful integration of technology.

A Commitment to Accessibility

Currently, Pulc lacks a defined business model. Ó Fathaigh expresses hope that the Department of Education might support them financially. However, he remains committed to keeping the platform free for teachers and students, emphasizing its accessibility.

Real-World Classroom Applications

Teachers like Kathleen Brady from Naas Community College have begun testing Pulc in their classrooms. Brady, who also teaches digital literacy, found Pulc especially beneficial during the Easter break when students often seek help with their essays.

Reliable and Effective Feedback

Brady noted that Pulc has proven reliable. “Nothing’s perfect, but neither am I,” she admits, explaining that she inputted previously marked essays to gauge Pulc’s accuracy. The tool’s suggestions were slightly lower than her assessments, which she views positively, indicating a conservative approach that encourages student growth.

Opening Doors to AI in Education

Brady hopes that tools like Pulc can help skeptical educators embrace AI. “AI is here, and we need to figure out how to harness it effectively,” she insists, advocating for a balanced view of technology’s role in education.

Alleviating Administrative Burdens

Brady advocates for the potential of AI to reduce administrative burdens, allowing teachers to focus on personal engagement with students. “I want to spend more time on proper teaching and pastoral care,” she explains, recognizing the challenges of grading large volumes of essays.

The Role of AI Advisory Councils

Alan Smeaton, a professor of computing at DCU and a member of the government’s AI Advisory Council, emphasizes the need for a broader conversation around AI in education. The council is pushing for technology to address inequalities in education, demonstrating its potential for positive change.

Learning from Successful Models

Smeaton highlights the success of tools like AI Lesson Assistant (Aila), developed by the Oak National Academy. Aila has been adopted by over 30,000 users, proving that AI can enhance teaching without compromising the educator’s role.

The Future of Learning

As Ó Fathaigh and Dillon work towards refining Pulc, they are part of a larger conversation about how technology can reshape education. Their goal is to create a tool that not only assists teachers but also enriches student learning, ensuring that every learner has the support they need to thrive.

A New Era in Education

The launch of Pulc represents a significant milestone in educational technology, illustrating the potential for AI to transform traditional learning methods. By reducing grading workloads and enhancing feedback, Pulc aims to create a more efficient and supportive educational environment.

Conclusion: Embracing Change

As education continues to evolve, tools like Pulc offer a glimpse into the future of learning. By balancing technological advancements with personalized teaching, Ó Fathaigh and his team are paving the way for a more equitable and efficient educational landscape. Embracing these innovations can empower both teachers and students, fostering a culture of continuous improvement in Irish education.

source

Recent News

Travel News

Lifestyle News

Fashion News

Copyright 2023 Varient – All Rights Reserved.